What is a good replacement for vanilla extract? If you’re a fan of baking or cooking but find yourself out of vanilla extract, don’t worry; there are several alternatives that can save the day. Vanilla extract is a versatile ingredient often used to add a rich, sweet flavor to a variety of dishes. However, if you’re looking for a substitute, it’s important to choose one that can mimic the flavor profile of vanilla without altering the overall taste of your recipe. Let’s explore some of the best replacements for vanilla extract.